Pure-FTPD error FTP Server did not properly shut down TLS connection

It's probably due to change in filezilla FTP client's TLS support similar to FTP Connection timeout / Uploads getting aborted
Have you tried a different FTP client ?

are you connecting via FTP/SSH using different devices on your home network ? i.e. laptop, desktop, mobile ?

If you are having pure-ftpd disconnection or connection issues when uploading many files at once, it could be CSF Firewall's DDOS protection for Port Flooding in play. You can verify this by doing a grep filter of your /var/log/messages log to see if there are entries with your IP address listed.

Where you replace 184.105.xxx.xxx with your ISP IP address or the IP address of user who is having issues uploading via pure-ftpd virtual FTP user

Code (Text):

grep -n 'Port Flood' /var/log/messages | grep '184.105.xxx.xxx'

If you're behind a VPN or proxy on your connection to pure-ftpd, your ISP IP address maybe masked so you can check to see what IP address your server is seeing for your SSH session using command below:

Code (Text):

echo $SSH_CLIENT

example output where your IP detected is the 1st column of ouput i.e. 184.105.xxx.xxx

Code (Text):

echo $SSH_CLIENT
184.105.xxx.xxx 54021 22

If there are entries that are returned from the grep filter, then your pure-ftpd disconnection or connection issues are related to PORTFLOOD protection in CSF Firewall /etc/csf/csf.conf settings.

You're hitting CSF Firewall Port Flood protection limits. Ideally, you want to limit your FTP clients max concurrent transfer limits and/or instead of uploading individual files, upload a zip file with all files then extract and move the files in place on server via SSH. Example of extracting a zip file via SSH can be seen in step 3 of Xenforo 2 setup. You can practice doing zip upload/extraction etc on test site domain until you are familiar with it.

Relevant settings in CSF Firewall /etc/csf/csf.conf settings file

Code (Text):

grep -C35 '# Port Flood Protection' /etc/csf/csf.conf

###############################################################################
# SECTION:Port Flood Settings
###############################################################################
# Enable SYN Flood Protection. This option configures iptables to offer some
# protection from tcp SYN packet DOS attempts. You should set the RATE so that
# false-positives are kept to a minimum otherwise visitors may see connection
# issues (check /var/log/messages for *SYNFLOOD Blocked*). See the iptables
# man page for the correct --limit rate syntax
#
# Note: This option should ONLY be enabled if you know you are under a SYN
# flood attack as it will slow down all new connections from any IP address to
# the server if triggered
SYNFLOOD = "0"
SYNFLOOD_RATE = "100/s"
SYNFLOOD_BURST = "150"

# Connection Limit Protection. This option configures iptables to offer more
# protection from DOS attacks against specific ports. It can also be used as a
# way to simply limit resource usage by IP address to specific server services.
# This option limits the number of concurrent new connections per IP address
# that can be made to specific ports
#
# This feature does not work on servers that do not have the iptables module
# xt_connlimit loaded. Typically, this will be with MONOLITHIC kernels. VPS
# server admins should check with their VPS host provider that the iptables
# module is included
#
# For further information and syntax refer to the Connection Limit Protection
# section of the csf readme.txt
#
# Note: Run /etc/csf/csftest.pl to check whether this option will function on
# this server
CONNLIMIT = ""

# Port Flood Protection. This option configures iptables to offer protection
# from DOS attacks against specific ports. This option limits the number of
# new connections per time interval that can be made to specific ports
#
# This feature does not work on servers that do not have the iptables module
# ipt_recent loaded. Typically, this will be with MONOLITHIC kernels. VPS
# server admins should check with their VPS host provider that the iptables
# module is included
#
# For further information and syntax refer to the Port Flood Protection
# section of the csf readme.txt
#
# Note: Run /etc/csf/csftest.pl to check whether this option will function on
# this server
PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;5;300"

# Outgoing UDP Flood Protection. This option limits outbound UDP packet floods.
# These typically originate from exploit scripts uploaded through vulnerable
# web scripts. Care should be taken on servers that use services that utilise
# high levels of UDP outbound traffic, such as SNMP, so you may need to alter
# the UDPFLOOD_LIMIT and UDPFLOOD_BURST options to suit your environment
#
# We recommend enabling User ID Tracking (UID_INTERVAL) with this feature
UDPFLOOD = "1"
UDPFLOOD_LIMIT = "100/s"
UDPFLOOD_BURST = "500"

# This is a list of usernames that should not be rate limited, such as "named"
# to prevent bind traffic from being limited.
#
# Note: root (UID:0) is always allowed
UDPFLOOD_ALLOWUSER = "named nsd"

###############################################################################
# SECTION:Logging Settings
###############################################################################

specifically this part

Code (Text):

# Port Flood Protection. This option configures iptables to offer protection
# from DOS attacks against specific ports. This option limits the number of
# new connections per time interval that can be made to specific ports
#
# This feature does not work on servers that do not have the iptables module
# ipt_recent loaded. Typically, this will be with MONOLITHIC kernels. VPS
# server admins should check with their VPS host provider that the iptables
# module is included
#
# For further information and syntax refer to the Port Flood Protection
# section of the csf readme.txt
#
# Note: Run /etc/csf/csftest.pl to check whether this option will function on
# this server
PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;5;300"

from CSF Firewall - CentminMod.com LEMP Nginx web stack for CentOS linked CSF Firewall readme file https://download.configserver.com/csf/readme.txt - section 16. Port Flood Protection

By default ipt_recent tracks only the last 100 IP addresses. The tracked IP
addresses can be viewed in /proc/net/ipt_recent/* where the port number is the
filename. Seems on my server that is at /proc/net/xt_recent i.e. for TCP port 21 the tracking IP file would be at /proc/net/xt_recent/21.

You can check if your server supports ipt_recent using csftest.pl script

Code (Text):

/etc/csf/csftest.pl

Code (Text):

/etc/csf/csftest.pl
Testing ip_tables/iptable_filter...OK
Testing ipt_LOG...OK
Testing ipt_multiport/xt_multiport...OK
Testing ipt_REJECT...OK
Testing ipt_state/xt_state...OK
Testing ipt_limit/xt_limit...OK
Testing ipt_recent...OK
Testing xt_connlimit...OK
Testing ipt_owner/xt_owner...OK
Testing iptable_nat/ipt_REDIRECT...OK
Testing iptable_nat/ipt_DNAT...OK

Viewing contents of xt_recent tracked TCP port 21 file at

Code (Text):

cat /proc/net/xt_recent/21

If IP address listed in that xt_recent TCP port 21 tracking file, and need to remove it type the following where IP address 184.105.xxx.xxx is prefixed with a minus

Code (Text):

cd /proc/net/xt_recent
echo -184.105.xxx.xxx >/proc/net/xt_recent/21

recheck if IP address was removed

Code (Text):

cat /proc/net/xt_recent/21

From CSF Firewall there's a default PORTFLOOD check against FTP port 21 for security. If more than 5 connections to tcp port 21 within 300 seconds, then block that IP address from port 21 for at least 300 seconds after the last packet is seen, i.e. there must be a "quiet" period of 300 seconds before the block is
lifted

Code (Text):

PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;5;300"

So check how many simultaneous download/upload connections is set in your FTP/SFTP client shown.

For Filezilla, those settings are under Settings -> Transfers (Concurrent transfers) section. Here there's unlimited concurrent download/uploads with 10 max simultaneous transfers.



If you want to use say max 10 concurrent transfers, you would backup CSF Firewall settings file /etc/csf/csf.conf and edit it to raise it from 5 hit count to 10 (max supported is 20 value)

CSF Firewall backup to file named b4-portflood-edit and list the backups

Code (Text):

csf --profile backup b4-portflood-edit
csf --profile list

example

Code (Text):

csf --profile backup b4-portflood-edit
Creating backup...
`/etc/csf/csf.conf' -> `/var/lib/csf/backup/1525327615_b4_portflood_edit'

csf --profile list

Configuration Profiles
======================
block_all_perm
block_all_temp
disable_alerts
protection_high
protection_low
protection_medium
reset_to_defaults

Configuration Backups
=====================
1525327615_b4_portflood_edit (Thu May  3 06:06:55 2018)
1525253709_cmm_default_tweaked (Wed May  2 09:35:09 2018)
1525253709_cmm_before_ptload_action (Wed May  2 09:35:09 2018)
1525253707_initial_default (Wed May  2 09:35:07 2018)
1525253706_pre_v12_03_upgrade (Wed May  2 09:35:06 2018)

Edit PORTFLOOD settings raising hit count from 5 to 10. You can use grep on /etc/csf/csf.conf to see the current value set for PORTFLOOD

Code (Text):

grep 'PORTFLOOD = ' /etc/csf/csf.conf

example output

Code (Text):

grep 'PORTFLOOD = ' /etc/csf/csf.conf
PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;5;300"

Then edit /etc/csf/csf.conf either manually to

Code (Text):

PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;10;300"

or via sed replacement edit

Code (Text):

sed -i 's|PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;5;300"|PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;10;300"|' /etc/csf/csf.conf

use previous grep command to verify the changes made by sed

Code (Text):

grep 'PORTFLOOD = ' /etc/csf/csf.conf                                                             
PORTFLOOD = "21;tcp;10;300"

restart CSF Firewall

Code (Text):

csf -ra

If you need to restore from the backup you made the previous settings use these commands.

The profile list will list csf profile backups look for listing name containing _b4_portflood_edit i.e. 1525327615_b4_portflood_edit and use that in restore command and then restart CSF Firewall

Code (Text):

csf --profile list
csf --profile restore 1525327615_b4_portflood_edit
csf -ra

Next edit your FTP client's max concurrent transfers to limit them to 10. For Filezilla that would be like



You can count how many concurrent pure-ftpd connections are being used server wide when uploading via pure-ftpd virtual ftp user. Assuming you're only user doing uploads, that number would be your concurrent pure-ftpd connections number.

In SSH use command for manipulating output for CSF Firewall command, csf -p which list current connections to server. The command below grep filters for pure-ftpd connections and further grep filters for nginx user and then counts the number via wc -l then divides that number by 2 as the list shows both outbound and inbound connections and then minus 1 for the initial established pure-ftpd connection

Code (Text):

echo $(($(csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx | wc -l)/2-1))

So for multiple file uploads via pure-ftpd virtual ftp user, if you run this command a few times you will get the number of connections. With above Filezilla max set to 10, you would see something like this after a few runs of the command

Code (Text):

echo $(($(csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx | wc -l)/2-1))
5
echo $(($(csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx | wc -l)/2-1))
10
echo $(($(csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx | wc -l)/2-1))
10

If you want view the actual connections instead of just the number use commands below:

Commnd output when you are idly connected to pure-ftpd without any file transfers, you will see inbound and outbound connection listed

Code (Text):

csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx

example output - inbound to TCP port 21 and outbound to TCP port 48970

Code (Text):

csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx
21/tcp     4/-  1     (31429/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
48970/tcp  4/-  0     (31429/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd

when actively or right after multiple file uploads via pure-ftpd virtual ftp user. The 11 mans 11 connections which are initial connection + 10 max concurrent = 11

Code (Text):

csf -p | grep pure-ftpd | grep nginx
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31429/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31915/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31917/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31918/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31919/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31923/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31925/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31926/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31929/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31930/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
21/tcp     4/-  11    (31933/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
30293/tcp  4/-  0     (31930/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
30324/tcp  4/-  0     (31933/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
31904/tcp  4/-  0     (31926/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
32775/tcp  4/-  0     (31919/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
35805/tcp  4/-  0     (31429/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
37105/tcp  4/-  0     (31915/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
37658/tcp  4/-  0     (31925/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
42541/tcp  4/-  0     (31917/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
43726/tcp  4/-  0     (31929/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
45697/tcp  4/-  0     (31918/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd
49106/tcp  4/-  0     (31923/nginx)        pure-ftpd (IDLE)                        /usr/sbin/pure-ftpd